Saturday, March 25, 2017

In Response to: “Valentine's Day: Important or Overrated?”


When I read Alyssa's post, “Valentine's Day: Important or Overrated?” I couldn't help but laugh to myself as I realized all the parallels with my own experiences with Valentine's Day.

Like Alyssa, this year was also my first year having a true valentine that I cared about. In the past, I have always despised the holiday because it reminded me that I was single, while many of my friends had their own boyfriends to keep them company. Even my celebration was like Alyssa's: my girlfriend and I went out to dinner and gave each other cute cards and little presents.

I agree that Valentine's Day has become an overly materialistic holiday, when everyone tries to show off how successful their relationships are on social media by posting pictures of the expensive jewelry and giant teddy bear their significant other bought them. However, it could be argued that every major holiday also suffers from this phenomenon. For example, Christmas is also now, in many cases, more about giving the perfect presents to loved ones than it is a religious holiday, as intended. It is perfectly acceptable to get your partner a small thoughtful gift rather than an expensive gift. In a study done at Stanford University, it was proven that the price of a gift matters much less than the quality and thoughtfulness of the gift. When gift-receivers were asked about expensive versus sentimental presents, they almost always chose the sentimental gift. However, when people were asked the same question as a gift-giver, they felt pressured to get a more expensive present. It is interesting that people don't trust their own opinions on the matter and instead are persuaded by the media and other social pressures to spend more money.

Still, I think Valentine's Day is important and should stay a tradition. The holiday does not have to be centered around lusty love and present-based courtship, but instead can be for everyone in your life that you love. Ever since I was a child, my parents would always get me and my sister a card and chocolates and even if we didn't have a significant other, there was always Mom and Dad. I also remember staying up late the day before Valentine's day putting together Valentines for each of my classmates, a requirement for our school parties. It is an adorable holiday that can also serve as a reminder to take time and appreciate everyone in your life that brings you joy and makes you feel loved. However, Valentine's Day seems to be losing some of this innocence and ubiquity in schools. Students aren't allowed to bring in treats because of health codes, and some schools have banned the celebrations altogether to avoid bullying. Valentine's Day should stay in schools to teach social skills, especially at a younger level.

Another argument against the holiday is that if a couple is happy, then they shouldn't need a specific holiday to dedicate to one another. Every day should be like Valentine's Day, full of love and appreciation for one another. However, even as a believer in true love, I know this is not realistic for any couple. Every couple will have days where the partners don't see quite eye to eye and have a disagreement or misunderstanding. There are long, stressful days when the couple does nothing for each other, and just goes to sleep without exchanging a word. In a study shown on yougov.com, when couples age, they forget to say I love you as often as new relationships. There is a dramatic reduction in how often couples say it after about 10 years of being together. If nothing more, Valentine's day is a much needed reminder to tell your loved one that you still love them.


Valentine's Day may be overly idealized and unnecessarily materialistic, but it is still sweet that as a culture, we have decided to devote a day to appreciating those who we love.   

No comments:

Post a Comment